I watch this clip at least once a day, and it give's me a lump in my throat every time I look at it. The reason why I watch it once a day, is that it reminds me of my tiger Karma. The ease, softness, confidence, nonchalance in which this horse performs piaffe pirouettes is the same ease, softness, confidence, nonchalance that Karma performed the corbette. There are some rare animals where it is 75% them, and only 25% human intervention. Never does he force this horse, instead stay's out of it way and let's it perform. But he insists that it perform to it capability. Watch at 1:22-1:25 and again at 2:44-2:48 when the horse given his great ability and confidence becomes "lackadaisical," and the rider respecting the animal and his capability's gently moves his right leg and "asks", "tells", and "promises" firmly without unfairness. Insisting that a great animal athlete stay at the peak of their capability's is not cruel or abusive. Insisting that any animal must do it to the same peak is where cruel and abusive enters. Preventing it from being great due to incompetence/lack of skills is not kindness, it is disrespect.
Saturday, February 14, 2009
Encouraging without Forcing--The ultimate in animal training knowledge.
Posted by
Wade G. Burck
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
Both Piaffers. The cowboy and this one are vway too long. What is the purpose of keeping the poor horse in this movement for such a long time.
Col. Herriott,
The cowboy is keeping his horse in what ever that is, way to long. The dressage rider isn't "keeping" his horse in the pirouette piaffe. The horse is "staying" there. Big difference in "forcing" and "letting".
Wade
Bullshit. They are both way too long and that horse is not doing it out of pure joy. The guy is using bit and spur my friend
Johnny,
At no point did I say either of the horses were doing it out of "pure joy". I am the first one to laugh at the often used defensive suggestion that they "love/enjoy performing." What I said was one was being "forced" and one was being "let". "Forced" is removing all options, "Letting" is finding out one option is better then the other. Big, big, difference between trained and subjugated.
Wade
Post a Comment