Judging with the honor system--Aurelia Cats Clinic

I wonder how Aurelia Cats rated young Merry Lu Casselly act, accepting the standard of creativity touted at Monte Carlo against her act. Ms. Cats was brutal in her critique of the contestants on the recent garbage "Celebrity Circus" in which she was a "celebrity judge." As you see below by her bio., Ms. Cats won a Gold Clown at Monte Carlo when she was 14. As Monte Carlo judging results are never posted and all that is known is who won and who didn't, I would love for Ms. Cats who apparently loves judging things and critiquing others, assuming she is honorable to tell us what standard she used with her act as an example of Gold to judge Merry Lu Casselly.
Here is the link to Ms. Cats trapeze/contortion act. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8FzxcT_DX


"After all, judge Aurelia Cats is a world-renowned circus performer! Aurelia has judged two of the top circus festivals in the world – the Monte Carlo International Circus Festival and the Paris International Circus Festival. She has won gold medals for outstanding performance in several circus festivals, including the 1989 Monte Carlo Festival for children."